Newburgh, New York Cookies

Cookies in Newburgh, New York are the perfect way to cure a sweet tooth! From the chocolately goodness of chocolate cookies and chocolate chip cookies to the lighter side with lemon cookies and almond cookies, there's something for everyone. If you're looking to buy cookies for your next party, browse our vendor database for bakeries in your area.

Newburgh cookie shops offer traditional favorites like sugar cookies and peanut butter cookies, but they may also specialize in other types of cookies. Looking for the best biscotti and Italian cookies in Newburgh, New York? Check out "little Italy," that's where you can usually find them!

Depending on the size of the cookie in Newburgh, estimate 2"“4 cookies per person. If you want to give cookies away as favors, consider personalizing your cookies with the name and date of the party. Bakers can use frosting, and sometimes photos, to create one-of-a-kind cookies for your party. Talk to your baker to find out if they can do anything special for your party cookies!

  • 1-3 Collegeview Ave, Poughkeepsie, NY
  • Shop Rite Plaza, Route 17M, Monroe, NY
  • 1545 Rte. 52, Fishkill, NY
Previous 1 3 4

Find a vendor